The Weekend’s Bits and Pieces – Week 4

by @FFA_Scanlon

Welcome to the first edition of “The Weekend’s Bits and Pieces” – A space where I will recap the weekends fantasy performances while providing some insight on what it may mean for the rest of the year.  I look forward to getting some feedback and interacting with you as the weeks progress.  Let’s get started.

Be Proud of Yourself:
There were plenty of draft day risks this year, and while a very large part of fantasy football is minimizing risk, those who take the right ones are usually the ones that come out on top.  For example, let’s say you belong to the population of people who bypassed the top tier of quarterbacks and took a risk on the only QB to have 20+ fantasy points in each of the first four games, including 22 in week 4 – Mr. RG III. Or the BC alum that has the highest QBR through the first four weeks and sits in second place in total fantasy points (after the aforementioned Redskins rookie) for the season – Mr. Matty Ice.  If you went all in on either of those guys, be proud of yourself, as week 4 made you all the more comfortable that this is likely to continue throughout the season.  Now, would I trade Aaron Rodgers straight up for Ryan or Griffin? No. But if either of those guys were my starting QB I would ignore the matchups and smile, patiently awaiting the 15-25 points that would soon be mine.

The two players who came with the most risk this year have the same initials: ACL.  Ok, that’s not true, but you see what I did there, right?  I’m not a knee expert, but Adrian Peterson and Jamaal Charles look just fine to me, and though it’s still early, through four weeks they seem as though they will be another risk that will pay off very kindly.  Peterson took a play from Wes Welker’s playbook, recovering so quickly it makes me question whether the wax healing bath from Wanted actually exists, has run very effectively and will undoubtedly find the end zone again very soon and very often.  Charles, coming off an absurd 288 yards from scrimmage and a TD in week 3 didn’t disappoint in week 4 with 115 yards from scrimmage and two TDs (one receiving).  If I’m picking one of these guys, it’s Charles.  Younger, longer recovery time, he’s starting to look real lonely in that backfield with Hillis still suffering from the Madden cover curse, and, I’m going to say it, has a bigger big-play potential.  It’s a small margin, as obviously Peterson can break out as well, but my personal goal for this week is to trade for Jamaal Charles. I’m convinced.

Finally, as the first week of byes has come to a close, congratulations to those who started Brian Hartline, Brandon Bolden, Jackie Battle, or Ryan Fitzpatrick (more-so if your league doesn’t count interceptions against you…).  Battle is an important player for any Ryan Mathews owner, as he’s shown potential, this week and in weeks passed, were he to have a role as the lead back.  I would expect it’s going to take Hartline the next four weeks to match his week 4 yardage, however the Dolphins offense has proven itself fairly efficient against some respectable defenses, and should be a good starting point for bye-week fill-ins.

Sorry You’re Disappointed:
The injury bug has plagued a couple players who returned this week, who you probably started, and who definitely let you down.  Forte was limited to just 13 carries, but when you see the Bears put up 34 points, it’s disheartening to see Forte not involved in the scoring.  If he gets healthy however, he should be the stud you drafted.  I can’t say I feel the same way about Stephen Jackson.  ”Stud” is probably too generous of a label to begin with, as most of his value comes from the fact that he’s one of the few players alone in his team’s backfield.  However if I could get 80 cents on the dollar on an injury prone RB whose team usually plays from behind and seems to be allergic to the end zone, I would take it.  Maybe even 75 – then you’re just getting quarters.

Other guys who belong on this list: Darren McFadden, Fred Jackson, Reggie Bush, and C.J. Spiller.  McFadden has one good game and three miserable ones, and doesn’t have an injury to point to this year (although, it’s still early).  He’s been frustrating, but I can’t help feel as though he’s one of the best, if not the best, buy-low options right now… I already talked about Miami’s offense, so a healthy Bush seems like a good option to me, and as far as Buffalo is concerned I would take Spiller for the upside, but can’t get too excited about either.  If I’m a Spiller owner I would recognize that week 1 and 2 are still fresh in peoples minds, and try to move him fast.

Don’t Get Too Excited:
I’m as excited about the Arizona Cardinals as the next guy is, but I’m not buying Andre Roberts.  We’ve seen many times the WR2 benefit when opposite a stud such as Larry Fitzgerald, but I have a difficult time believing that you’re looking at that next Anquan Boldin. You know, when he was good.  I also think Jason Witten’s 100+ yards and TD were fluky, and while you could obviously do worse, just, you know, don’t get too excited.

Finally, and most importantly, trade Michael Turner.  The Atlanta Falcons are throwing the ball, and while Turner’s receptions have seen an increase in the last couple years, it isn’t enough that you can count on a 60 yard TD reception each week.  Or anything close to it, for that matter. Not only that, but Jaquizz Rodgers is sneaking up on the worn down back, taking some of his early down carries and being productive enough with them to stay in the mix.  Turner isn’t useless, but if I was a betting man, I would say his value is only going to go down from here – All it would take is one big game from Rodgers.

Now You Can Get Excited:
Raise your hand if you thought Julio Jones was Matt Ryan’s favorite target.  Once you’re done explaining to whoever is around you why you’re hand is up, if you’re also a Roddy White owner, get excited.  Roddy has been one of the most consistent fantasy wideouts over the last couple years, and Julio is, overall, going to help that remain the same, not hurt it.  So I guess it’s less about excitement, and more a sigh of relief.  While Julio Jones is still going to be productive, there’s nothing to worry about as far as White is concerned.  The stud sophomore receiver not named Jones, A.J. Green, stayed atop the fantasy wideout list by adding another 100+ yards and a TD in week 4 – I think him and Dalton are friends.  Expect it to continue.  That I would be excited about…

You are also free to get excited about Steven Ridley and Willis McGahee.  A lot of people were skeptical here, including yours truly, but these two workhorses, one young and one old, used week 4 to continue establishing themselves as solid RB1 options.  They’ve had slow weeks, but they’re getting the ball, and they’re getting it on the goal line.  It’s hard to ask for much more than that.

And while we’re talking about Denver, let’s end today with Peyton Manning, who sure hasn’t disappointed so far.  20+ points in three of four weeks, making Decker and Thomas look pretty good, and came at a significant draft day bargain.  He didn’t make the “Be Proud of Yourself” section, because I still think if an angry linebacker got a clean shot at him, you could very quickly have a whole to fill at QB. However, if he plays 16 games, I promise I’ll put him in that section at the end of the year.

Good luck in week 5, I’m sure it will give us all much more to be excited about.

Share
Posted in The Weekend's Bits and Pieces | 1 Comment

Who to pick #1

A final Analysis by @FFAdvisor_Matt

Entering the 2012 fantasy draft there are three players who are clearly ahead of the rest of the field. No matter what your format is Arian Foster, Ray Rice and LeSean McCoy should be the top three backs taken. Their average draft position (ADP) backs that up: At two decimal points Foster is 1.15, Rice is 1.16 and McCoy is 1.27. In a nutshell, McCoy usually gets picked third while Rice and Foster flip flop back and forth as the number one overall. But who should truly be the number one pick of 2012?

The first thing we need to look at is last year’s stats – as conventional wisdom says “those who don’t know their history are doomed to repeat it.”

Arian Foster 278 rush, 1274 yards, 4.4 ypc, 53 rec, 617 yards, 16 TD’s

LeSean McCoy 273 rush, 1309 yards, 4.8 ypc, 48 rec, 315 yards, 20 TD’s

Ray Rice 291 rush, 1364 yards, 4.7 ypc, 76 rec, 704 yards, 16 TD’s

Looking at last year’s stats it’s almost a wash. Rice had the most rushing yards, Foster did the most damage through the air and McCoy found the endzone the most. Factor in Rice played all sixteen games, while McCoy missed one and Foster missed three. This year there are determining factors that will make the cream rise to the top. The first thing we’ll do is eliminate one.

While McCoy found the endzone the most, he also had the fewest amount of catchs and rushes. He touched the ball an average of 19.5 times per game. Eagles head coach Andy Reid has already said he used McCoy too much last year and doesn’t want to make that mistake again. Dion Lewis, Bryce Brown and Chris Polk have all proven in the pre-season that they can help lighten the load for McCoy. Reid and the rest of the coaching staff are very high on their young stable of backs and plan on getting them plenty of action to keep LeSean fresh for the end of the season and more importantly the playoffs. With all that, I believe McCoys ADP of 1.3 is correct. We can eliminate LeSean from contention for the #1 overall.

Ray Rice is the definition of a workhorse running back. In 2009 Rice was handed the keys to the offense. He’s relished the role ever since and last year was no exception. He averaged 4.7 receptions per game that resulted in a per game average of 44 yards thru the air. On the ground he battered his competition to the tune of 85 ypg. He also found the goal line in nine games for sixteen touchdowns. He achieved the century mark six times on the ground and twice through the air. There is no competition to steal carries from Rice. His 22.3 touches per game should stay about the same. Running Backs coach Wilbert Montgomery said “You don’t buy a new car and put it in the driveway or just park it in the garage. You buy it, you drive it.” In terms of schedule, Rice will run against the 19th hardest schedule in terms of run defense. In week 15 and 16 he’ll have a tough task when he’ll face a rising Broncos defense and the always tough New York Giants.

Arian Foster was simply a beast last year. Although he missed three games he blew up in the games he played. He put up over 100 yards on the ground in seven of the thirteen games and also hit triple digits twice through the air. He reached pay dirt in nine games for a total of twelve TD’s. He averaged 98 rushing yards and 47 yards though the air. Foster was targeted 5.5 times per contest and hauled 4.0 receptions per game. All told he touched the ball an average 24.9 times per game. As we know, the more opportunities you get the better chance great things can happen. This year he’ll run against the 24th hardest run defense. More importantly he’ll get the Colts and Vikings weeks 15 and 16. Those are great match-ups for our playoffs. Although he shares duties with Ben Tate, there is no threat to Foster’s value. In the games that both Foster and Tate played, Foster averaged 19.5 carries to 9.5 for Tate. In other words, Arian Foster is the man in Houston, make no mistake about it.

After splitting hairs it comes down to two determining factors for me. With both going into the season 100% healthy I want the guy who is going to get the ball the most and do the most with it! More touches means more points. The main is to get to the final two weeks and win our league. Whether your league uses playoffs or not, I want the guy with the easiest schedule to close out the season. Houston plans to run the ball down your throat as usual, while the Ravens want to throw it more. Arian Foster gives me an easier schedule, better playoff schedule, more touches and is in an offense that will continue to make him a fantasy stud.

While Rice and Foster will continue to trade places going 1-2 in fantasy drafts with McCoy being drafted a respectable third. Everything points to Arian Foster ending the year as the fantasy running back king.

Share
Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

2012 FFAdvisor.com Plan

Hi folks and welcome back to FFAdvisor.com, your one stop shop for evaluating all things Fantasy Football related!

We’re excited for 2012 and ready to start kicking off some new content to you in the next week. Including:

  • New website reviews
  • Updates of previous website reviews
  • Addition of user rankings of Fantasy Sports websites
  • Relaunch of the FFAdvisor.com forums/community where you can talk sports and fantasy football with some of the most knowledgeable players in the world

To help out we have added additional folks to the FFAdvisor team. We’ll get them introduced here shortly, but more hands and good minds means more content each week for all of you.

Looking forward to a great year and don’t forget to follow us @FFAdvisorcom on twitter

Dave

Share
Posted in Uncategorized | 1 Comment

Week 7 Accuracy Rankings

Below you’ll find our week 7 accuracy rankings. Note that no one really hit the bullseye this week.

In other news, we may not have a write up this week, as Dave had a basement flooding incident… anyone know a good heating repair guy??

Any specific questions about last week or the upcoming week, hit us up: @ffadvisorcom

Share
Posted in Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Week 7 Best of Breed Rankings

Our best of breed rankings are a custom blend of the most accurate sites and experts on the internet for each fantasy football position. They are posted Saturday morning to assist in your final start and sit decision making. These rankings are for standard scoring leagues. If you have a specific question (PPR, or flex related) that these rankings don’t address please don’t hesitate to let us know on Twitter @ffadvisorcom we usually respond within 60 minutes!

 

QB: CNNSI Mack, FF Toolbox, and a dash of CNNSI Beller

  1. Aaron Rodgers
  2. Drew Brees
  3. Tony Romo
  4. Mathew Stafford
  5. Ben Roethlisberger
  6. Cam Newton
  7. Philip Rivers
  8. Matt Schaub
  9. Joe Flacco
  10. Matt Ryan
  11. Jay Culter
  12. Josh Freeman
  13. Matt Cassel
  14. Matt Hasselbeck
  15. Colt McCoy
  16. Tim Tebow
  17. Tavaris Jackson
  18. Sam Bradford
  19. Kevin Kolb
  20. Curtis Painter
  21. Kyle Boller
  22. Mark Sanchez
  23. Charlie Whitehurst
  24. Christian Ponder
  25. Blaine Gabbert
  26. John Beck
  27. Matt Moore
  28. AJ Feeley

RB: A heavy dose of CNNSI Beller, a bit of CNNSI McQuade and CNNSI Composite score

  1. Darren McFadden
  2. Ray Rice
  3. Adrian Peterson
  4. Arian Foster
  5. Matt Forte
  6. Rashard Mendenhall
  7. Ryan Mathews
  8. Michael Turner
  9. Chris Johnson
  10. Beanie Wells
  11. Maurice Jones-Drew
  12. Willis McGahee
  13. Earnest Graham
  14. Daniel Thomas
  15. Darren Sproles
  16. DeMarco Murray
  17. Steven Jackson
  18. Marshawn Lynch
  19. Ryan Torain
  20. Jackie Battle
  21. James Starks
  22. Mark Ingram
  23. Mike Tolbert
  24. Jonathan Stewart
  25. DeAngelo Williams
  26. Shonn Greene
  27. Montario Hardesty
  28. Donald Brown
  29. Delone Carter
  30. Ryan Grant
  31. Michael Bush
  32. Ben Tate
  33. Tashard Choice
  34. Reggie Bush
  35. Maurice Morris
  36. Marion Barber
  37. Tim Hightower
  38. Knowshon Moreno
  39. Isaac Redman

WR: A bit more than 50% of Fantasy Sharks, tempered with equal portions of CNNSI Sabino and Yahoo Behrens

  1. Calvin Johnson
  2. Greg Jennings
  3. Dwayne Bowe
  4. Steve Smith (CAR)
  5. Miles Austin
  6. Mike Wallace
  7. Dez Bryant
  8. Marques Colston
  9. Roddy White
  10. Brandon Marshall
  11. Pierre Garcon
  12. Anquan Boldin
  13. Larry Fitzgerald
  14. Vincent Jackson
  15. Jordy Nelson
  16. Greg Little
  17. Percy Harvin
  18. Eric Decker
  19. Nate Washington
  20. Santonio Holmes
  21. Sidney Rice
  22. Mike Williams (TAM)
  23. James Jones
  24. Reggie Wayne
  25. Kevin Walter
  26. Brandon Lloyd
  27. Steve Breaston
  28. Santana Moss
  29. Malcom Floyd
  30. Hines Ward
  31. Doug Baldwin
  32. Lance Moore
  33. Preston Parker
  34. Antonio Brown
  35. Early Doucet
  36. Danario Alexander
  37. Darrius Heyward-Bey
  38. Torrey Smith
  39. Damian Williams
  40. Devin Hester
  41. Nate Burleson
  42. Robert Meachem
  43. Mike Thomas
  44. Titus Young
  45. Dexter McCluster
  46. Johnny Knox
  47. Plaxico Burress
  48. Jacoby Jones
  49. Jabar Gaffney
  50. Mohamed Massaquoi
  51. Julio Jones
  52. Arrelious Benn
  53. Dane Sanzenbacher
  54. Denarius Moore
  55. Brian Hartline

 

TE: A balance of CNNSI Beller and CNNSI Composite, with a touch of CNNSI McQuade

  1. Jimmy Graham
  2. Jason Witten
  3. Brandon Pettigrew
  4. Tony Gonzalez
  5. Jermichael Finley
  6. Owen Daniels
  7. Antonio Gates
  8. Fred Davis
  9. Dustin Keller
  10. Greg Olsen
  11. Kellen Winslow
  12. Jared Cook
  13. Dallas Clark
  14. Ed Dickson
  15. Visanthe Shiancoe
  16. Lance Kendricks
  17. Benjamin Watson
  18. Heath Miller
  19. Kevin Boss
  20. Joel Dressen

 

Kicker (CBSSportsline’s Richard, Yahoo’s Funstn and Pianowski)

  1. Dan Bailey
  2. Jason Hanson
  3. Mason Crosby
  4. John Kasay
  5. Nick Novak
  6. Robbie Gould
  7. Steve Hauschka
  8. Shaun Suisham
  9. Bill Cundiff
  10. Adam Vinatieri
  11. Rob Bironas
  12. Matt Bryant
  13. Dan Carpenter
  14. Matt Prater
  15. Josh Scobee
  16. Neil Rackers
  17. Jay Feely
  18. Phil Dawson
  19. Nick Folk
  20. Olindo Mare
  21. Ryan Longwell
  22. Josh Brown
  23. Jason Elam
  24. Kris Brown

D/ST (CNNSI Composite/Sabino and NFL.com’s Rnak)uade)

  1. Ravens
  2. Steelers
  3. Packers
  4. Bears
  5. Cowboys
  6. Redskins
  7. Broncos
  8. Raiders
  9. Saints
  10. Lions
  11. Jets
  12. Texans
  13. Buccaneers
  14. Chiefs
  15. Brons
  16. Chargers
  17. Seahawks
  18. Panthers
  19. Falcons
  20. Titans
  21. Vikings
  22. Dolphins
  23. Cardinals
  24. Colts
Share
Posted in Rankings | Leave a comment

Week 6 Cumulative Accuracy Rankings

Lots of changes on tops with 2 more weeks in the books and the addition of the CNNSI team of experts to the cumulative rankings.

If you only have time to go to ONE site this week, you’ll want to pull from the top of our overall accuracy list. As a reminder we require a site be evaluated at least three weeks before they can be included in our cumulative rankings.

This information is used to build our best of breed rankings that we release on Saturday mornings, which takes the most accurate experts for each position and blends their projections for that week using a formula that weights their rankings based on their overall accuracy score.

At the top of our overall ranking we see CNNSI represented twice. The highest score is actually the composite rankings of all of the CNNSI experts, right behind that composite score is Beller, with a very strong accuracy ranking mostly on the strength of #1 scores in RB and TE. We’re glad to see CNNSI’s individual experts doing so well, given how poorly CNNSI’s rankings were last season. As a reminder, please please please, do not go to http://sportsillustrated.cnn.com/fantasy/football/ nfl/player_projections/2011/07/quarterback.htm to get their rankings. Those are the ones that are horribly inaccurate.

The mainstream sites continue a strong season of fantasy projections this year. Yahoo has three of the top 10 accuracy rankings with Pianowski, Funston, and Behrens. CNNSI also has three of the top 10 and NFL.com has two of the top 10. The only non mainstream media or sports company represented in the top ten in overall accuracy currently is FF Toolbox.

The past two weeks have been especially unkind to the Fantasy Sharks, who came out of week 4 in the #1 position and now find themselves at the bottom of the pack. We firmly believe their accuracy levels will pick back up, but as we mentioned before, their rankings come with a high degree of risk. They are not conservative, they make very bold calls and when they are right, the jump well above the competition, but when the are wrong, it’s just as big of a hit the other way.

 Best of breed rankings will be made up of the following this week:

  • QB: CNNSI Mack, FF Toolbox, and a dash of CNNSI Beller
  • RB: A heavy dose of CNNSI Beller, a bit of CNNSI McQuade and CNNSI Composite score
  • WR: A bit more than 50% of Fantasy Sharks, tempered with equal portions of CNNSI Sabino and Yahoo Behrens
  • TE: A balance of CNNSI Beller and CNNSI Composite, with a touch of CNNSI McQuade
  • D/ST: CNNSI Composite, CNNSI Sabino, and NFL.com’s Rank in nearly equal components
  • Kicker: A whole lot of CBS Richard, with a bit of Yahoo’s Funston and Pianowski

Remember if there is a site that we should be tracking, let us know on twitter @ffadvisorcom

Best of Breed rankings first thing Saturday Morning!

Share
Posted in Cumulative, Rankings | Leave a comment

Week 6 Accuracy Rankings

Welcome to week 6 of our site/expert accuracy rankings! Last week (posted on Tuesday) we welcomed RosterWatch.com to our rankings, this will be their second week being assessed. You’ll notice there are several sites that have not been included in our past two weeks rankings including the FFAdict and Recliner QB Fantasy Corner, the reason for that is simply it is an opt-in effort to be assessed by FFAdvisor. These folks have to key their projections into our template for us to be able to run the numbers on them, if they are unable or too busy to get them to us in a week we are obviously not able to include them in our rankings.

As always we removed any players that were injured during the game, we only assess what experts actually rank, we make no assumptions for players they don’t rank.

Best Calls
At Quarterback we see FFToolbox and our friends at Fantasy Godfathers at the top of the list, both nailing the category with a bullseye for week 6. Toolbox was very accurate on Matt Schaub (15th projected versus 16th actual), Sam Bradford (20th versus 21st actual) and Tony Romo (7th projected versus 9th actual). Both the Godfather and Toolbox were right on for Matt Ryan calling him at the 8th projected versus the 6th actual, which wsa important as many had Ryan 15+ as a marginal starter in week 6.

The FantasySharks are usually at the top of a category, it’s just not usually RB! Previously strong in the QB category the sharks logged a #1 ranking in RB this week on the back of being appropriately conservative on Darren Sproles (23rd projected versus 26 actual – against an industry average of 15 or so) and being right on top of Steven Jackson as a must start ranking him at #11 versus his #11 actual performance.

NFL.com’s Dameshek continues a strong showing in his first year in FFAdvisor’s rankings by winning the WR category in the face of a challenging week of projections where studs like Roddy White, Gregg Jennings and Desean Jackson all really disappointed. Dameshek’s best call was slotting Brandon Marshall in as a WR2 with a 16 ranking against a 10th overall performance against an industry average of the low 20s (Revis Island, and swearing to get thrown out in the first half will scare off even the hardiest of fantasy experts apparently!). AJ Green was another great call, pegging him at 8th versus a 9 actual when you had other experts ranking him as low as #20.

It’s worth highlight CNNSI’s Mack for an insanely great (nod to Steve Jobs for that turn of a phrase) D/ST score. Mack nailed the Jets as the #1 D/ST, was just off on the Bengals at a 4 versus 3 actual and the Falcons at 10th versus a #9 actual. Very strong showing in a very difficult category (historically speaking).

Worst Calls
We do our color coding so at a glance you (and us) can do a visual analysis of how accurate sites are projecting positions that week. We’ve never had two categories where neither had any sites labeled “Wildly Innacurate” It was such an aberration that we tripled checked our input rankings and math, but it was completely true. So no real “bad” calls to highlight from the RB and QB categories, and universal applause to all of the experts and sites we track for that!

It wasn’t all good news this week however. We did see some low scores in the WR category. CBS’s Richard had a rough week being amongst the lowest on our #1 WR Marques Colston (22 projection), our #2 WR Jordy Nelson (21 projection), and being among the highest on Steve Smith (CAR) with a 3 ranking versus his 35th overall actual score.

ESPN’s fantasy experts of Matthew Berry and Christopher Harris struggled mightily in the TE category . Actually most of our experts this week had difficulty here, which is especially interesting in comparison to a very high week 5 TE rankings. Bye weeks play havoc both with fantasy line ups and expert fantasy rankings we believe. Berry and Harris were overly optimistic on Owen Daniels abilities to penetrate the tough Baltimore D slotting him at #5 versus a 29 actual ranking, they were also among the lowest on Fred Davis with 15/13 projections against his 7 actual. Obviously Vernon Davis and Jermichael Finley both being no shows really skews these numbers.

Next up is Cumulative rankings published on Thursday which will include the updates from both week 5 and week 6 and then remember to check back Saturday for our all important, one of a kind, best of breed fantasy rankings, the last word for making your start and sit decisions on Sunday!

Got questions, is there another site we should be tracking? Let us know on Twitter @ffadvisorcom

 

Share
Posted in Rankings | Tagged | Leave a comment

Week 5 Accuracy Rankings

Share
Posted in Rankings | Tagged | Leave a comment

Who2Start.com Efficacy Rating

At FFAdvisor we’re constantly searching for new and innovative ways of bringing insights and clarity to the fantasy football landscape. Recently the folks at Who2Start.com asked us if we could measure the accuracy of their service offering: Personalized expert fantasy football advice either purchased by the individual question or by subscription. It as a very different challenge for us to think about rather than our normal exploration of the accuracy of positional rankings.

We’re pleased to announce that with the help of a few of our friends from MIT we’ve built a process and an algorithm to measure the efficacy of their work and in future weeks/years believe we can apply it to assess the use/value of start/sit and other more complex fantasy football offerings!

Methodology: Each question was evaluated on a scale from 0-10. The reason for this is because many questions had multiple components: i.e. “start two out of four players” or “pick the best two waiver wire candidates out of the following six.” When an answer was 100% correct it received a 10. When it was 100% wrong it received a 0. Anything in between was assigned a score based on the combination of answers provided versus the best possible outcome that could have been recommended.

The score doesn’t represent “accuracy” per se as our other weekly scorecard, but instead measures efficacy. Efficacy is simply “the ability to produce intended results.” We’ve evaluated Who2Start.com’s rankings for each of the past 5 weeks and the results are below:

Through the first five weeks of the season their personalized fantasy football service is delivering very good advice with an average efficacy rating of 69.6%. To put it simply, anything over 50% means essentially they’ve been more correct than they’ve been incorrect. We will continue to report on their efficacy throughout the season, but we have no problem recommending them for folks who are looking for more personalized fantasy football advice.

In addition we are creating a baseline of randomly selected twitter interactions to put a “crowd sourced” view of advice efficacy against this personalized expert driven approach. We hope to be able to report the initial results of that exploration next week!


Share
Posted in Rankings | Tagged , , , , | 1 Comment

Best of Breed Rankings for Week 5

Welcome to our best of breed rankings! The last word in start and sit decisions for you each week! Below you’ll find our rankings based on the top 3 sites in each position. Questions? Hit us up on twitter @ffadvisorcom!

Quarterbacks:
Based on rankings of Fantasy Sharks + FFToolbox + KFFL

1. Aaron Rodgers
2. Cam Newton
3. Michael Vick
4. Drew Brees
5. Matthew Stafford
6. Tom Brady
7. Matt Ryan
8. Philip Rivers
9. Ryan Fitzpatrick
10. Mark Sanchez
11. Josh Freeman
12. Eli Manning
13. Kevin Kolb
14. Matt Schaub
15. Ben Roethlisberger
16. Donovan McNabb
17. Tarvaris Jackson
18. Alex Smith
19. Matt Hasselbeck
20. Jay Cutler
21. Kyle Orton
22. Jason Campbell
23. Curtis Painter
24. Andy Dalton
25. Matt Cassel
26. Blaine Gabbert

Running Backs:
Based on rankings of Yahoo/Evans + Yahoo/Funston + FFAddict

1. Arian Foster
2. Darren McFadden
3. Adrian Peterson
4. LeSean McCoy
5. Fred Jackson
6. Matt Forte
7. Maurice Jones-Drew
8. Ryan Mathews
9. Chris Johnson
10. Frank Gore
11. Ahmad Bradshaw
12. Darren Sproles
13. Chris “Beanie” Wells
14. Jahvid Best
15. Cedric Benson
16. Mike Tolbert
17. Michael Turner
18. Joseph Addai
19. LeGarrette Blount
20. Shonn Greene
21. Willis McGahee
22. Jonathan Stewart
23. Ryan Grant
24. Isaac Redman
25. LaDainian Tomlinson
26. BenJarvus Green-Ellis
27. James Starks
28. Stevan Ridley
29. Mark Ingram
30. DeAngelo Williams
31. Thomas Jones
32. Marshawn Lynch
33. Michael Bush
34. Brandon Jacobs
35. Pierre Thomas
36. Dexter McCluster
37. C.J. Spiller
38. Kendall Hunter
39. Delone Carter
40. Rashard Mendenhall
41. Knowshon Moreno
42. John Kuhn
43. Earnest Graham
44. Jacquizz Rodgers
45. Shane Vereen
46. Ben Tate

Wide Receivers:
Based on rankings of Fantasy Sharks + FFAddict +  ESPN Harris

1. Calvin Johnson
2. Larry Fitzgerald
3. Steve Smith
4. Hakeem Nicks
5. Greg Jennings
6. Mike Wallace
7. Roddy White
8. Wes Welker
9. DeSean Jackson
10. Vincent Jackson
11. Julio Jones
12. Dwayne Bowe
13. Brandon Lloyd
14. Steve Johnson
15. A.J. Green
16. Sidney Rice
17. Jordy Nelson
18. Jeremy Maclin
19. Santonio Holmes
20. Percy Harvin
21. Marques Colston
22. Eric Decker
23. Jacoby Jones
24. Mike Williams
25. Reggie Wayne
26. Antonio Brown
27. Nate Washington
28. Plaxico Burress
29. Lance Moore
30. Michael Crabtree
31. Denarius Moore
32. Victor Cruz
33. Mike Thomas
34. Pierre Garcon
35. Deion Branch
36. David Nelson
37. Mario Manningham
38. Robert Meachem
39. Kevin Walter
40. Johnny Knox
41. Darrius Heyward-Bey
42. Jacoby Ford
43. Malcom Floyd
44. Nate Burleson
45. James Jones
46. Titus Young
47. Steve Breaston
48. Austin Collie
49. Josh Morgan

Tight Ends:
Based on rankings of NFL.com/Dameshek + Yahoo/Pianowski + Sports Outlaws

1. Jermichael Finley
2. Rob Gronkowski
3. Jimmy Graham
4. Vernon Davis
5. Owen Daniels
6. Tony Gonzalez
7. Dustin Keller
8. Brandon Pettigrew
9. Greg Olsen
10. Jermaine Gresham
11. Kellen Winslow
12. Jared Cook
13. Marcedes Lewis
14. Aaron Hernandez
15. Dallas Clark
16. Scott Chandler
17. Visanthe Shiancoe
18. Randy McMichael
19. Kevin Boss
20. Jeremy Shockey
21. Todd Heap
22. Heath Miller
23. James Casey
24. Tony Scheffler

Kickers:
Based on rankings of KFFL + CBS/Richard + Yahoo/Funston

1. Neil Rackers
2. Jason Hanson
3. Nick Novak
4. Mason Crosby
5. Sebastian Janikowski
6. John Kasay
7. Ryan Succop
8. Stephen Gostkowski
9. Rian Lindell
10. Mike Nugent
11. David Akers
12. Robbie Gould
13. Matt Bryant
14. Lawrence Tynes
15. Jay Feely
16. Connor Barth
17. Adam Vinatieri
18. Alex Henery
19. Steve Hauschka
20. Rob Bironas
21. Nick Folk
22. Ryan Longwell

Defense/Special Teams:
Based on rankings of Yahoo/Funston + Yahoo/Pianowski + Bruno Boys

1. New York Giants
2. Detroit Lions
3. San Diego Chargers
4. Houston Texans
5. Minnesota Vikings
6. Tennessee Titans
7. Cincinnati Bengals
8. New Orleans Saints
9. Green Bay Packers
10. Pittsburgh Steelers
11. San Francisco 49ers
12. Tampa Bay Buccaneers
13. Philadelphia Eagles
14. Kansas City Chiefs
15. Chicago Bears
16. Jacksonville Jaguars
17. Indianapolis Colts
18. New England Patriots
19. New York Jets
20. Arizona Cardinals
21. Oakland Raiders
22. Buffalo Bills
23. Atlanta Falcons
24. Seattle Seahawks
25. Carolina Panthers
26. Denver Broncos

Share
Posted in Projections | Leave a comment